ShippyPro Blog - Shipping Solutions Library

Carrier Liability vs. Third-Party Insurance: 2026 UK Merchant Coverage Guide

Written by Ashley Brown | Feb 10, 2026 12:08:39 PM

Carrier Liability is the limited legal obligation of a transport provider to compensate a shipper for loss or damage based on predetermined weight-based limits. Unlike insurance, it serves as a baseline protection governed by national and international transport laws. It matters to UK e-commerce merchants because standard liability often covers only a fraction of an item’s retail value.

Carrier Liability is a weight-based legal minimum, not a comprehensive safety net. While every shipment includes basic coverage, payouts are determined by the weight of the parcel rather than its actual market value, often leaving merchants with significant financial gaps. Solutions like ShippyPro bridge this gap by allowing merchants to automate third-party shipping insurance and multi-carrier shipping rules, ensuring that high-value orders are protected for their full invoice value rather than a few pounds per kilogram.

What Is Carrier Liability? — Expanded Definition

Carrier Liability refers to the maximum amount a shipping company is legally required to pay if a package is lost, stolen, or damaged while in their custody. In the UK, this is typically governed by the Road Haulage Association (RHA) or BIFA terms and conditions.

Crucially, this is not shipping insurance. Liability is a contractual limit of the carrier’s responsibility. For example, if you ship an 800g smartphone worth £900 via a carrier with a liability limit of £13 per kg, your maximum payout would be roughly £10.40. Semantic variations like standard carrier cover or contractual liability all point to this same weight-based restriction that ShippyPro helps merchants navigate through better risk distribution.

How Carrier Liability Works — Step-by-Step

  1. Contractual Agreement: When you generate a label via ShippyPro, you agree to the carrier’s Terms and Conditions (T&Cs).
  2. Transit Custody: Liability begins once the carrier scans the parcel into their network.
  3. Incident Occurrence: A loss, damage, or theft event is recorded in the branded tracking system.
  4. Claim Filing: The merchant must file a formal claim, often within a strict window of 7 to 14 days.
  5. Liability Assessment: The carrier checks if the item was on the "prohibited items" list and if the packaging was sufficient.
  6. Payout Calculation: If approved, the carrier pays based on the weight of the item or a small "up to" amount (e.g., £20).

Key Features of Carrier Liability vs. Third-Party Insurance

  • Weight-Based Limits: Most UK road carriers limit liability to £1.30 per kg (RHA basic) or similar metrics.
  • Limited Exclusions: Liability does not cover "Acts of God," strikes, or "inherent vice" (damage caused by the nature of the product).
  • Full Value Reimbursement: Third-party insurance covers the Order Value, including shipping costs.
  • Theft After Delivery: Standard liability usually ends at the doorstep; third-party insurance often covers "porch piracy."
  • Global Conventions: International shipments are governed by CMR (road) or Montreal Convention (air), each with its own "SDR" (Special Drawing Rights) calculation.

Benefits of Third-Party Shipping Insurance

Using a dedicated insurance provider alongside your shipping automation platform provides peace of mind and financial security. Unlike carrier claims, which can take 30–90 days, third-party insurers often settle within 7–10 days.

  • Margin Protection: Prevents a single lost pallet from destroying a month’s profit.
  • Customer Experience: Allows you to reship immediately to the customer while the claim is pending.
  • Comprehensive Coverage: Includes "Hidden Damage" where the box looks fine but the contents are broken.
  • Brand Loyalty: By using ShippyPro to handle reshipments quickly, you turn a negative delivery experience into a loyalty-building moment.

Who Uses Enhanced Coverage? — Use Cases

  • High-Volume Electronics Stores: Shipping laptops or phones where the value-to-weight ratio is extreme.
  • Luxury Fashion Brands: Protecting designer handbags and high-end apparel from theft.
  • International Sellers: Merchants shipping to high-risk regions where Parcel shipping software indicates higher loss rates.
  • B2B Wholesalers: Using ShippyPro to protect bulk pallet shipments sent via DHL or FedEx.

How to Choose Between Liability and Insurance

  1. Analyze Your SKU Value: If your average item value is under £20 and over 2kg, carrier liability might suffice.
  2. Review Carrier T&Cs: Check the specific Carrier Page for DPD, Royal Mail, or Evri to see their default limits.
  3. Check Claims Windows: If your operations team is small, you need the longer filing windows offered by third-party insurance.
  4. Evaluate "Non-Delivery" Rates: Use ShippyPro Analytics(Optimizer) to see which carriers have the most incidents and apply insurance to those specific routes.

Shipping Protection Software Options & Comparisons

While carriers like UPS and FedEx offer "Declared Value" (which is essentially an extension of their liability), third-party specialists often provide better rates.

  • ShippyPro: Integrates directly with insurance providers to allow "one-click" insurance at the point of label generation.
  • SendCloud / ShipStation: Offer basic internal insurance options but may have limited UK-specific carrier liability deep-dives.
  • Shipsurance / InsureShip: Dedicated third-party providers that can be connected to ShippyPro for automated coverage.

Carrier Liability for European E-commerce

Shipping within Europe adds the complexity of the CMR Convention. Under CMR, the carrier’s liability is limited to 8.33 SDR per kilogram (roughly £9.00/kg).

UK merchants shipping to the EU via GLS, Poste Italiane, or Correos must account for the fact that post-Brexit customs delays can sometimes invalidate "time-sensitive" liability claims. ShippyPro is built for European logistics, ensuring that the correct customs documentation (CN22/CN23) is generated to prevent liability rejections based on "improper paperwork."

Carrier Liability & Insurance Statistics

  • The global shipping insurance market is projected to reach $38.5 billion by 2027.
  • UK e-commerce businesses using third-party insurance report a 45% faster claims resolution time compared to carrier-direct claims.
  • 73% of UK consumers say they are less likely to shop with a brand again if a parcel is lost and not replaced within 5 days.
  • ShippyPro users who automate insurance for items over £100 reduce their "unrecovered loss" capital by up to 92%.
  • Porch piracy in the UK increased by 22% in the last year, an event rarely covered by standard carrier liability.

How to Get Started with ShippyPro Shipping Protection

  1. Sign up for a free ShippyPro account — Access the dashboard in under two minutes.
  2. Connect your store — Link Shopify, WooCommerce, or Magento.
  3. Connect your Carriers — Add your accounts for DPD, Royal Mail, UPS, and more.
  4. Set Insurance Rules — Go to the automation section and set a rule: "If Order Value > £50, Apply Insurance."
  5. Ship and Track — Generate labels and monitor for exceptions. If a loss occurs, use your ShippyPro data to file a claim instantly.

 


Explore Other Resources & Tools

 

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the main difference between carrier liability and shipping insurance?

Carrier liability is a weight-based legal limit (e.g., £1.30/kg) included in the shipping price. Shipping insurance is an optional, value-based service that covers the full invoice price of the goods.

Does ShippyPro offer its own insurance?

ShippyPro allows you to easily add insurance to any shipment through integrations with third-party providers or by using the carrier's declared value options, all within a single workflow.

Does DPD liability cover theft after delivery?

Usually, no. If the carrier provides a "Proof of Delivery" (photo or GPS), their liability ends. Third-party insurance is often required to cover theft after the driver has left.

How long do I have to file a claim?

Most carriers require notice of damage within 3 days and a formal claim within 7–14 days. Third-party insurers often allow up to 30 days.

Why was my carrier claim rejected?

Common reasons include "insufficient packaging," "prohibited items," or "filing outside the time limit."

Is ShippyPro free to use for claims?

ShippyPro provides the tracking data and documentation needed to win claims, which is included in the platform's standard features.